Two listings say "Windermere, FL 34786." One is a few blocks from the shell-surfaced side streets near Main Street, and the other is in Keene's Pointe. Do they pay the same property tax rate, call the same police department and use the same trash service?
They don't, and the mailing address won't show you why. The incorporated Town of Windermere covers 2.2 square miles. Its own website says most "Windermere" addresses are not incorporated. The town lists Summerport, Keene's Pointe, Casabella, Belmere, 535 and the area around Reams Road as outside its limits. The same page notes that the town has no apartments, condos or townhomes inside its boundaries. If you're comparing a condo or townhome with a Windermere address, it sits in unincorporated Orange County.
The town line affects buyers more than most people expect. On 2026 rates, a parcel inside the small town carries a lower total millage than a typical unincorporated parcel with the same ZIP code. The town also runs its own police, trash and road systems.
The rate gap on 2026 bills
The Orange County Property Appraiser's 2026 chart of final millage rates lists each tax district's total. Inside the town, the Town of Windermere levies 3.7425 mills. Unincorporated parcels pay Orange County's "UTD & Fire EMS" rate of 4.6480 mills instead. Both sides pay the same countywide general, school, library and water management district levies.
Here is how the district totals compare on the 2026 chart:
| 2026 tax district | County, school and other district levies | Municipal or unincorporated levy | Total mills |
|---|---|---|---|
| Town of Windermere, district 36 | 11.3826 | 3.7425 | 15.1251 |
| Several common unincorporated Orange County districts | 11.3318 | 4.6480 | 15.9798 |
The county general, school, library and St. Johns River Water Management District rates are identical on both sides and add up to 11.3318 mills. The town district's subtotal on the chart is 0.0508 mills higher than that.
The difference is about 0.85 mills. A mill is $1 of tax for every $1,000 of taxable value. On $500,000 of taxable value, 0.85 mills works out to roughly $427 a year in the town's favor. Some unincorporated districts on the chart total more than 15.9798, because special districts add their own lines. One of those is the Windermere Water & Navigation district at 0.2528 mills, which applies to some parcels outside the town. Compare district totals, not just the municipal line.
The town's rate has also held steady. The West Orange Times & Observer reported in August that the town was keeping 3.7425 mills, the rate it has used since 2018. The Town Council adopted that rate with a $12,464,394.17 budget for fiscal year 2026-27 at its Sept. 16 hearing, the Observer reported. According to the hearing agenda, the adopted rate is 4.27% above the rollback rate of 3.5893 mills. Even so, the levy stayed the same while assessed values changed.
Why the smaller government charges the lower rate
Orange County's budget overview for fiscal 2026-27 says the Sheriff and Fire Rescue each have dedicated property-tax millage in the unincorporated area, used only for their operations. In unincorporated west Orange County, the Orange County Sheriff's Office patrols through its Sector III, which covers areas of Windermere.
Inside the town, the same jobs are handled differently:
- Police: The Windermere Police Department says its officers provide uniform patrol 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.
- Fire: Ocoee Fire Department firefighters also serve the Town of Windermere, according to the West Orange Times & Observer. The town council's Aug. 11 agenda listed an interlocal agreement with the City of Ocoee for permit inspection, plan review and fire services.
- Public works: The town handles its own street maintenance and stormwater, and maintains town buildings, grounds and parks.
- Permits: Building permits and inspections go through the town's provider, PDCS. Planning and zoning go through Wade Trim.
Water and sewer don't follow the town line the same way. The town's building services page sends water leaks and water or sewer emergencies to Orange County Utilities. On either side of the line, ask early in the transaction which water and wastewater services a particular parcel actually has.
Trash shows up on the tax bill
Trash service is where the town line shows up most in daily life. Inside town limits, refuse collection is mandatory. It's billed once a year through the property tax bill at the start of each October-to-September fiscal year, and the payment goes to the Orange County Tax Collector. WastePro runs the routes on this schedule:
- Garbage on Tuesdays and Fridays
- Recycling on Tuesdays
- Yard waste on Wednesdays
- Items at the curb by 7 a.m.
- Two large-item special pickups a year, scheduled by calling WastePro
WastePro provides the recycling bins. Inside the town, residents supply their own trash and yard waste bins, and the town won't reimburse the cost. The town asks people outside its limits not to use its system and to contact Orange County Utilities, because requests sent to the wrong place cause delays or missed pickups. A new owner in Summerport or Belmere who searches "Windermere trash pickup" will land on the town's page first. That page is for the 2.2 square miles inside the line.
Shell roads inside the line
Inside the town, some streets are surfaced with shell instead of pavement. In March 2026, the West Orange Times & Observer reported that crews were scheduled to grade roads and lay new shell on Eighth Avenue between Main Street and East Boulevard and on Oakdale Street between Eighth and 10th avenues. The paper's report refers to "dirt" Main Street. The same report described lime rock being graded on West Second Avenue to prepare for paving, and new concrete curbs on Bessie Street and Eighth Avenue. In April, the Observer listed drainage, grading and curb work scheduled around Second Avenue, Third Street, Butler Street and Fernwood Park.
If you're looking at an in-town home, find out whether its street is paved or shell. That affects the daily drive, and the town maintains both kinds of street.
Amendment 3 in the 2026 election
Florida voters decided the Nov. 3 election's Amendment 3 on homestead exemptions and assessment caps with 61.98% voting yes in the Florida Department of State's first set of unofficial returns. Amendments need 60% to pass.
Checking a parcel before you compare homes
The town tells anyone unsure of their status to verify it with the Orange County Property Appraiser at (407) 836-3111, not to rely on the mailing address. A short checklist for comparing two Windermere listings:
- Look up each parcel's tax district with the Property Appraiser.
- Compare district totals on the 2026 final-rate chart, including any special-district lines.
- Confirm water and wastewater service for each parcel.
- Note who handles trash, police and fire on each side.
Quick answers
Is Keene's Pointe in the Town of Windermere? No. The town names Keene's Pointe, along with Summerport, Casabella, Belmere, 535 and the Reams Road area, as outside its limits.
Can I buy a condo inside the town? The town says there are no apartments, condos or townhomes within incorporated Windermere.
Did the town raise its rate for 2026-27? The rate stayed at 3.7425 mills, adopted Sept. 16, 2026.
Comparing a home inside the town with one that only has the address is a question about tax districts and services, and I'm glad to sort through it with you parcel by parcel. If you're relocating or adding a rental to your portfolio in west Orange County, my Windermere neighborhood page is a good place to start. When you have two addresses in mind, reach out to Mike Long and we'll look up both tax districts together. Let's Connect.